Business Guide
simplicable technology guide   »  enterprise architecture   »  advanced enterprise architecture concepts   »  enterprise architecture scorecard

Enterprise Architecture Scorecard

        posted by , July 17, 2011

It's not possible to calculate a ROI for enterprise architecture. The value of enterprise architecture lies in influence — which can't be quantitatively measured.

Enterprise Architecture Scorecard

There are four major ways that EA generates value: decision support, tactical wins, project governance and architectural reference materials. The following scorecard assigns a RAG (red, amber, green) status for each area by architectural domain:

enterprise architecture scorecard

Decision Support

Enterprise Architecture facilitates business and IT transparency. Examples of EA decision support capabilities include:

- executive dashboards
- trusted advisors
- identifying strategy gaps
- identifying opportunities for common solutions
- mapping business strategy and IT strategy
- mapping strategy, metrics, applications, data and projects to a business capability map
- supporting solution architects and IT management (enabling teams to think global; act local)
- presentations (marketing the architectural vision and roadmap)

Tactical Wins

Enterprise Architects are heavily involved in long term strategic planning. However, tactical considerations are critical to business success — EA must show results on a quarter over quarter basis.

Examples of EA tactical wins include:

- consulting services for business and technical initiatives
- use of the EA repository to resolve project issues
- use of the EA repository to resolve operational issues
- Mergers & Acquisitions support
- high level involvement in critical solutions


Architecture is the result of a series of projects — EA must actively influence projects.

- Project governance (reviewing the architectural approach of major projects)
- Mandating or influencing projects to leverage common solutions
- Identifying projects that are inconsistent with business and IT strategy
- Gaps and opportunities that lead to project initiation
- Influencing solution architecture


Enterprise Architects build out a repository of critical architectural knowledge — this repository is a significant part of EA's value proposition:

- business and technology strategy that influence projects and initiatives
- vocabularies and capability maps that become the language of business and technology
- reference architectures that become the basis of solutions
- use of EA materials for onboarding and training
- EA materials that support major business initiatives such as mergers and acquisitions

Track who uses the EA repository — and survey users on the value of EA materials to business results.

Notes on Scoring

Scoring EA is inherently qualitative. Don't try to come up with a systematic score — it just isn't realistic.

Scoring should be relative to the maturity of the organization and the EA team. For example, many EA teams have no influence on business projects — so this box can be greyed out.

The scorecard should link to a list of accomplishments for each box in the grid.

3 Shares Google Twitter Facebook

Related Articles

Enterprise Architecture
How to architect an organization.

A guide to cloud computing including cheat sheets, best practices and metrics.

Cloud computing demystified.

Templates for enterprise architecture and solution architecture.

Learn about the 10 most dangerous Enterprise Architecture pitfalls.

Recently on Simplicable

8 Enterprise Architecture Risks

posted by Anna Mar
Enterprise Architecture (EA) is supposed to help manage IT risks — but is it possible that EA itself introduces new risks?

Security Through Obscurity

posted by Anna Mar
Security through obscurity is generally considered a bad idea ...

Zombie Armies of The Digital Frontier

posted by Anna Mar
An quick explanation of botnets.

IT Security Guide

posted by John Spacey
A guide to information security including cheat sheets, best practices and checklists.


about     contact     sitemap     privacy     terms of service     copyright